"Give me the liberty to know, to utter, and to argue freely according to conscience, above all liberties. Truth was never put to the worse in a free and open encounter..."
~ Milton
Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.
~Benjamin Franklin

Reading:
A Fistful of Euros
Andrew Tobias
Angry Liberal
Archy
Bad Attitudes
Common Dreams
Fablog
Hullabaloo
Informed Comment
Madelaine Kane
Mahablog
Obsidian Wings
Off the Kuff
Orcinus
Sarah Kendzior
War and Piece
Washington Monthly

Books
The Emerging Democratic Majority (Judis & Teixeira)
Lies and the Lying Liars Who Tell Them (Franken)
Rush Limbaugh Is A Big Fat Idiot (Franken)
The True Believer (Hoffer)
Still Being Bushwhacked

All Book Reviews
Race, Gender, and Sexuality
It's always "us" vs "them"
Women's March on (fill in your location)
Children learn what their parents teach them.
You Got My Support. But.
Even Endangered Penguins Do It

All Race, Gender, and Sexuality
Campaigns and Voting
Where do we go from here?
It's always "us" vs "them"
Some interpretations
On and on I go
Just appalled

All Campaigns and Voting
Lecture Circuit
It Was 40 Years Ago Today
July 2, 1964
Pledge
May 14-15, 1970
The Erotica of Bare Knees

All Lecture Circuit
Media
The Liberal Media, At It Again
Fairly UNbalanced
P.S.
What's this?
OHMIGOD

All Media
Big Brother
Shoulda' Guessed
Where did my country go?
You know what you never thought you'd read?
Not in his name
Sleight of Hand

All Big Brother
World O'Blog
It's Vocabulary Time!
They wrote it
Mighty-fine blogging
Other People Said....
Phillipines

All World O'Blog
Aimless Ranting
It's always "us" vs "them"
So, I'm thinking with half my brain
Do You Know Peter?
Long, Little Privacy Rant
My Takeaway

All Aimless Ranting
Archives
February 05, 2017 - February 11, 2017
January 22, 2017 - January 28, 2017
January 15, 2017 - January 21, 2017
November 13, 2016 - November 19, 2016
October 09, 2016 - October 15, 2016

All Weekly Archives


Electioneering
Open Secrets
Political Wire Exit Polls
Politics1
Polling Report

Information
American Research Group
Center for Democracy and Technology
Center for Public Integrity
Center on Budget and Policy Priorities
Congressional Report Cards
Death Row Roll Call
DebtChannel.org
Democracy Now
Economic Policy Institute
FairVote Colorado
Foreign Policy In Focus
Global Exchange
Human Rights Watch
Independent Judiciary
Inequality
Institute on Money in State Politics
Institute for Public Accuracy
JobWatch
Lying in ponds
Media Reform
Media Transparency
Move On
One World
Open Democracy
Pew Research Center
Project Censored
Public Citizen Health Research Group
Stockholm International Peace Research Institute
Take Back The Media
The Urban Institute
WHO Outbreak News

Connections
XML & RDF
Peevish for PDA



Blog Directory


Search








Credits
Powered by Movable Type

Site Design by Sekimori





All content © 2002-2005 Anne Zook

November 22, 2005
Don't let the door hit you....

Finally, the "warring factions" in Iraq have come to an agreement. They've found one point upon which they all concur.

They want us gone.

Posted by AnneZook at 10:34 AM


Comments

If the Iraqi Government wanted coalition forces out, the resolution would have clearly given an timeframe as opposed to the generic "specified timetable."

The language regarding "resistance is legitimate" gives the Sunnis cover to come into the political process. Given the tribal nature of the society, the Sunnis need a way to participate while still "saving face." Goodness, political posturing and compromising to get a consensus soundbite document out to the media by politicians running for office...sounds almost "democratic."

You choose to portray this story in a cynical light. This resolution is just posturing. -Another perspective would consider this action as good news for the Coalition and the pro democracy forces in Iraq. Given the country (most of the region) has only a history of authoritarian regimes, the agreement is a positive sign of cooperation. An easy one to be sure given a common foil; however, we are at the 10 year anniversary of the Dayton Accords and Bosnia is now just reaffirming the intent to move beyond the weak power-sharing structure set up by that agreement.

Shouldn't we be encouraging baby steps as opposed to looking at every event as an opportunity to knock something down?

Posted by: Col Steve at November 23, 2005 08:51 AM

Yes, I'm cynical about it. We've heard so many lies and seen so much evidence of wrongdoing coming from the Bush Administration around this war that everything about it makes me cynical...except the body counts, which make me sad.

If the 'warring 'factions' in Iraq are coming to a democractic consensus on any issue, yes, it's a good thing. The fact that the one thing they're united around is the idea that they don't like us is not so inspiring.

(snip) (Okay. I went off on a rant, but I deleted it.)

Posted by: Anne at November 23, 2005 09:57 AM

Anne -
It's a stretch to interpret the resolution words as saying they don't like us. What they don't like is US forces staying indefinitely to provide security as opposed to them - “immediately setting up a national program to rebuild the armed forces in a way that will allow them to control the security situation and put an end to terrorist operations.

Guess what? We don't want to be there indefinitely either.

Posted by: Col Steve at November 23, 2005 10:39 AM

Granted.

But I still maintain that the most logical interpretation of the resolution is to say, "they want us to leave."

It's hardly necessary to put forth a formal resolution saying, "hey, we'd rather not be an occupied territory forever and ever."

It isn't as though a nation needs to say that or the world will assume they're thrilled with being overrun by foreign troops, you know. I think most sane people just sort of assume that a nation doesn't want to be occupied by uninvited foreign troops.

And I still think there could be more to the "insurgency is legitimate" clause than you think there is, but I'm willing to stop for a while and consider the "face-saving" option you suggested.

Posted by: Anne at November 23, 2005 11:29 AM